
As publishers, we find ourselves being asked the same questions rather frequently – whether about the book industry in general or our company in particular. For easy reference, here goes:
In any book, there are three primary processes (and costs) required to get to a finished product: compiling the information (doing the writing and sourcing the pictures), pre-production (from editing to layout) and printing. Let’s consider a simple 50,000-word black-and-white softcover book.
If you can deliver a near-perfect manuscript (NB: this is virtually impossible) that requires the barest of edits, it is possible to copy edit, proof and lay it out (typeset) and design a simple but workable cover for around R10,000. You could then digitally print one reasonable trade-quality copy for R100 or so, or 500 copies for under R15,000. For larger non-digital (litho) print runs, usually offering slightly better quality, you’d be looking at R40,000 for 2,500 copies.
Genres that we really can’t help with include:
- Children’s books (a hugely competitive and oversubscribed market, by the way)
- Self-help books or any other spiritual wellness type guides
- Romantic fiction
We try our best at Burnet Media to give all proposals a fair crack because a) we’ve been on the authors’ side of this equation, and b) you never know what hidden gems are waiting to be unearthed.
1. The you’re-not-for-us letter
Straightforward enough: if you’ve sent your proposal for a book on crustaceans of the West Coast to an imprint that puts out children’s fiction, you can expect this response. This happens surprisingly often, by the way, probably the result of the misguided belief that mass-sending general-approach emails to every publisher in the book is a wise move. (It’s not; targeting a handful of publishers, mentioning the publishing manager by name, is the way to go.) You may also get this response if the tone and style of your writing is at odds with the imprint in question.
Bottom line: your idea and/or writing doesn’t fit their brand.
The good news: you might fit another brand.
The bad news: you’ve wasted your time and annoyed an editor.
2. The we-like-your-idea-but-it’s-too-risky letter
This is the standard – and understandable – rejection when the editor reading your proposal thinks your writing is lovely but your idea just won’t sell. Such a response might be couched in phrases like “we are unable to take risks in tough economic times” or “our schedule is secured for the foreseeable future”. This may be a conservative call, when an editor doesn’t know what to make of a proposal or if cashflow is a problem, and it may be made reluctantly. But it may also be a sound judgment call: most book ideas are risky and don’t work.
The bottom line: it’s tough getting published.
The good news: at least you aren’t rubbish; you may get some ideas to tighten up your proposal or to approach a specific publisher.
The bad news: this may actually be the you-are-rubbish letter in disguise.
3. The you-are-rubbish letter
As it sounds, you are rubbish. It can be horrendously difficult to hear it after all the time and effort and expectation that’s gone into your proposal and draft writing, but most proposals and manuscripts just aren’t good enough.
The bottom line: it’s tough getting published.
The good news: the Beatles, James Joyce and Stephen King were all repeatedly rejected.
The bad news: you’re probably not James Joyce.
If you are fobbed off without an explanation, it is likely to be reason 3. This is all assuming you get a rejection letter, though – many publishers don’t even bother.

